The earliest recorded burial was in 1740. Stones in the churchyard mark the forebears of families who live near Lamington today. Four ministers of the church are here, the Rev. James McCrea, the Rev. Jeremiah Halsey, the Rev. William Boyd, and the Rev. William Blauvelt. John Honeyman, the spy who supplied the intelligence that assured Washington's victory at the Battle of Trenton, is buried here, as are 35 other soldiers of the Revolution, and veterans of the French and Indian Wars and the War of 1812. In 1983 a new section of the cemetery was opened and a memorial garden was planted for the repose and remembrance of members of the Lamington Church family.